The NYS Library has provided JSTOR with access to rare prison newspapers from our holdings. JSTOR has digitized those newspapers and made them freely available to the public as part of their collection, American Prison Newspapers, 1800s-present: Voices from the Inside.
Supported by a Mellon Foundation grant, this collection has been in development for five years and counting. We are glad to be contributing partners on this project. Since historical prison newspapers can be obscure, this is a chance to amplify those voices from within. Our contributions include the following titles:
Star of Hope

Published by incarcerated individuals since 1899, this official monthly newspaper circulated throughout several New York State Prisons. Read Star of Hope on JSTOR.
The Prison Observer

Now known as Roosevelt Island, Blackwell’s Island was once the site of the New York County Jail. Incarcerated individuals housed there published their own official monthly newspaper. Read The Prison Observer on JSTOR.
The Star-Bulletin

Published at Sing Sing Prison in Ossining, this monthly newspaper features color print, poetry, sports, and the arts. It’s on par with other newspapers of the day. Read The Star-Bulletin on JSTOR.
The Summary

Published weekly at the New York State Reformatory in Elmira, this prison newspaper dates back to the 19th century. It includes railroad schedules, local news, and aggregate data on incarcerated individuals. Read The Summary on JSTOR.
The New York State Museum’s dog treadmills, shared as part of their Look at This social media series, inspired us to use New York State Library resources to discover related materials in our collections.
U.S. Patents at the NYS Library
The NYS Library has been a United States Patent and Trademark Resource Center since 1871. The collection includes nearly everything the USPTO has published and distributed, ranging from early material in paper, through microforms, CD/DVDs and up to their current online databases. The collection also includes many commercially published resources. You can use the patent collection for both patentability searches and historical inquiries.
Using NYS Library patent resources, we located several 19th-century patents for machines powered by animals—often referred to as animal power, horse power, or dog power. They were built to power equipment ranging from sewing machines to butter churns to washing machines. One of many dog churn patents was issued to Franklin Traxler of Scottsburgh, NY on June 12, 1866. This iteration was a rotary-style churn in which the animal walked on a circular, rotating platform. The text of the patent explained the use of a cam-wheel and friction-rollers to move a lever that powered the churn.
Exploring NYS Butter Production through Government Documents
Since the NYS Library's creation in 1818, we have functioned as a repository of official New York State government documents and currently have the largest collection of NYS documents in the world.
Two government publications in the NYS Library's collections provide a snapshot of NYS butter production toward the end of the nineteenth century. A report titled summary of butter and cheese made in factories in the state of New York : during the season of 1892 identified 468 factories engaged in butter production (255 exclusively focused on butter, the other 213 producing both butter and cheese).
The table below displays columns for towns in Chautauqua County, with columns reporting the number of separate butter and cheese factories with a record of pounds made for each. There is another column to record the number of factories that made both butter and cheese with product totals in pounds, as well as a column to view the total weight of butter and cheese made in each town. In Chautauqua County in 1892, 26 factories produced butter and 42 produced cheese.
According to a map showing the location of the butter and the cheese factories in the State of New York, U.S.A., 1899 / compiled and issued by the Commissioner of Agriculture of the State of New York, the number of butter factories in Chautauqua County in 1899 had grown to almost 40.
The blue circles on the map indicate the location of butter factories while green dots indicate cheese factories. The full map shows the highest concentrations of butter and cheese production in the central and western parts of the state with lower activity in the southeast, across the mountainous Adirondack and Catskill terrain, and in the areas surrounding the Finger Lakes.
In real life, this map is over four feet wide! Download the file from our Digital Collections and zoom in for the highest quality viewing experience.
A Habit of Disappearing
A February 15, 1832 issue of the New England Farmer contains an article by J. Buel of Albany titled "Making and Preserving Butter." The article lays out the steps for making butter: mainly to ensure proper nutrition for cows, separate the cream, and churn before it becomes bitter. The speed of churning is advised to be regular and moderate: “If too slow, and at intervals only, the separation is tedious and uncertain. If violent, the cream is much too heated, and yields a white insipid butter.”
A footnote from this section, shown below, discusses the use of dogs in this capacity: "The dog churn is in general use in many counties, particularly upon the borders of the Hudson. In Orange we hear this in operation in a summer morning at every farm house. It is a great saving of labor to the family, which has a barrel of milk to churn daily. In one place I saw a sheep treading the diagonal platform, and another tied at hand to relieve him."
Naturally, the effectiveness of dog-powered churns depended on the willingness of the dog to power the machine. According to newspaper anecdotes discovered through the NYS Library's electronic resources, this could prove difficult.
A June 28, 1891 article from the Buffalo Courier Express titled "Gould in a Dog-Churn: Why the Railroad King Left his Country Home" loosely credits the dog churn as influencing Jay Gould's decision to leave his family's farm to pursue individual success. Gould, the notorious Gilded Age businessman, is quoted as saying his family's dog churn "had a great deal to do" with his career:
“My father had a little dairy farm in Delaware County, and the special products of that farm were butter and cheese. We had a rotary churn, which was operated by a treadmill on which we worked a large dog and sometimes a sheep. In course of time the dog and the sheep came to understand what was in store for them when they saw the persons about the place setting up the churn. Thereupon they were in the habit of disappearing. On such occasions, to supply the missing motor, I was pressed into service, and eventually I came to understand that when the churn was preparing, I was in danger of involuntary servitude; and so I, also, used to disappear.”
Another disappearing act is noted in the Western New-Yorker out of Perry, New York on October 22, 1891. Ponto, a mastiff, "got to know when churning day came around as well as any in the house. On the morning of that day he would loiter about the kitchen door until he was fed, and as soon as he heard the note of preparation--the bringing of the cream jugs, preparing the churn, &c.--he would put for the woods and would not be seen again until night."
Be sure to check out the NYS Museum’s Look at This series on social media. Follow this space as we dig into NYS Library collections and electronic resources to discover what related material we can find!